Over the tracks coffee

5374 Niagara Carthage Rd, Southern Pines, NC 28387, United States
+1 910-635-2438
$$$ Cafe , Coffee shop
(37 Reviews)

Welcome to Over the Tracks Coffee, a charming café nestled in beautiful Southern Pines, NC. Located at 5374 Niagara Carthage Rd, this cozy spot is your new favorite destination for artisanal coffee and delightful snacks, all served with a personal touch from the owner, Scott.

As soon as you step inside, you are greeted by a warm atmosphere and the aromatic scent of freshly brewed coffee—it's impossible not to feel right at home. Scott takes immense pride in crafting each cup of coffee to perfection, ensuring that every customer receives exactly what they desire. Whether you walk in for a simple black coffee or a lavish latte with all the bells and whistles, you can trust that you’ll leave satisfied.

Here, coffee isn’t just a drink; it’s an experience. Customers rave about the smoothness and freshness of Scott's brews. Teo Owen, a satisfied customer, notes how Scott is attentive to every detail, making sure your drink is precisely how you like it. And don’t forget to pair your coffee with one of Anne’s famous energy cookies—light and satisfying, these cookies are the perfect accompaniment to kick-start your day or enjoy during a relaxing afternoon break!

According to Alice Shuart, the coffee here is, quite simply, the “smoothest, tastiest and freshest” she's ever had. Reviews confirm that Over the Tracks Coffee isn't just about the coffee; it's about the experience. The café has garnered a reputation for not just serving great drinks but providing excellent customer service too. Phillip Touchton praises Scott’s genuine passion for coffee and his commitment to ensuring every guest leaves happy, while Rainey Jarrell highlights the café's family-friendly vibe, where kids can choose between delightful hot chocolate or cold chocolate.

A visit to Over the Tracks Coffee is more than just a stop for caffeine—it's a chance to connect with a local gem where everyone feels welcomed. Even if you find yourself arriving moments before closing time, don’t be surprised if Scott offers to whip you up a custom drink, as recorded in Maddison Booth’s delightful encounter. Every visit is unique, and that’s part of the charm of this café.

Whether you're a local or just passing through, Over the Tracks Coffee is a must-visit destination—ideal for those cozy mornings, midday breaks, or casual meet-ups. Come for the coffee, stay for the warmth and community spirit. You won’t be disappointed!

To contact the café or check for updates, call +1 910-635-2438.

Offerings
Coffee
37 Reviews
Teo Owen

16 Aug 2025

Scott makes a great cup of coffee. Whatever you want in it he'll do it! And pick up a bag of Anne's energy cookies too. Both coffee and cookies are delish!

alice shuart

13 Aug 2025

Recently visited, the coffee is the smoothest, tastiest and freshest I have ever experienced. The energy cookies are a great combo for a perfect start to my day! Highly recommended!

Phillip Touchton

09 Aug 2025

Great cup of joe there. You can tell that the owner loves what he does. Much to his nature, Scott is always works to make his customers happy. He tries very hard to make sure he knows how each customer prefers their coffee, and takes careful consideration to their opinion when he introduces a new coffee.

toshia dunbrack

14 Jul 2025

Got a Latte and homemade cookies. They both were amazing!! Scott was so nice and it took him no time to whip up my speciality coffee!!!

Maddison Booth

05 Jul 2025

Stopped in today and it ended up being closed, Scott greeted us instantly and despite being closed he made us our coffees and showed us around. Really nice guy and the coffee is well worth the stop!

Kim Brenner-Delp

16 Jun 2025

I stumbled on this place taking a detour from my usual route to Whispering Pines from Southern Pines and I'm so glad I did! The lattes are great... quality coffee beans used, and the owner Scott is very attentive to your coffee preferences. Great service! He's got a cool workshop on site too. I highly recommend stopping by, barely a 10 minute drive from downtown Southern Pines.

Rainey .Jarrell

10 Jun 2025

Wonderful morning date with the family. Butterscotch Walnut cookies were delicious and coffee made to perfection. The owner was very attentive to how hot, how sweet everything was. Kids loved how they could choose between hot chocolate or cold chocolate!

Jack Leenaarts

06 Jun 2025

Excellent coffee(s) and friendly service; good baked goods, too!. A little out of the way, but definitely worth the trip. See you again soon.

Join the Over the tracks coffee Newsletter

Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.